American Orientalism
April 11 Fan Lecture 3
- Race as social construction
- Asian Americans are thought of to have less artistic value as a result of their STEM stereotyping
- Stereotypes are similar to Halloween costumes
- Firms (institutions) decide which costumes to create and how to market them
- Customers (society) purchase the most popular costumes without a care about if the costume is racist or not
- Two main stereotypes for Asian-Americans: model minority and yellow peril
- Orientalism
- Orientalism by Edward Said is the main text regarding orientalism
- Focuses on the Middle East, but all of Asia is typically included in the idea of Orientalism
- Tracks the fantasy of Orientalism in literature and academic history
- Orientalism defined as the belief that the West and East are inherently different, but the West has a distinct superiority over the East
- The idea of the Orient became a career as opposed to a culture, a topic to become an expert in rather than a human story
- “The Orient can never understand their own culture, so the West must understand it for them”
- Can be thought of as a B story; career, all show, no substance
- Orientalism by Edward Said is the main text regarding orientalism
- Stereotypes and historical variability
- Originally created by white liberals to understand minorities
- Historical variability references the idea that stereotypes regarding Asians have changed over time
- The model minority
- Academically focused, career focused, successful
- Economically stable, heterosexual, have children
- Obedient and passive, making them easy to manage and hard workers
- Conceived by a writer tryinvg to understand why Japanese-Americans were so successful despite being placed in internment camps
- Used to distinguish “friendly” Asians from “enemy” Asiansm especially during the Cold War and era of Maoism
- Racism is not a barrier for minorities, as they can still succeed (as evidenced by Japanese-Americans)
- Despite the apparent racism, this view was inherently leftist; the success is based on culture rather than race
- Moynihan Report was the first to discuss the model minority stereotype; emphasized how black people were less moral than other races, causing their failure
- Today, the stereotype is thought of as a myth and is used by Asian-American intellectuals to fight against racist stereotypes
- Focuses more on economic success
- Disingenuous to think of it as a myth; certain Asian-American groups are hyperselected which causes the model minority stereotype to be true in a sense
- Important to ask: Why is considering the model minority a myth advantageous? How is its existence as not being a myth important?
- Yellow peril: then and now
- Conceived in the 13th century and continued until the mid-20th century
- Belief that Asians are not individuals but a mob of “worker bees” that work towards conquering the world
- Labor Unions were supportive of the Chinese Exclusion Act despite the immigration of Chinese workers to the US for work on the Transcontinental Railroad during the Gold Rush
- Jack London, “The Unparalleled Invasion”
- London was a Socialist who emphasized his identity as a white man (was a white supremacist)
- Tried to write fiction regarding economic uncertainty
- In Invasion, Chinese efficiency is thought of as a threat compared to Japanese ingenuity as a model minority
- After the destruction of China in Invasion, London realized a socialist utopia where whites were at the top of a racial hierarchy and Chinese were at the bottom
- Hypocrisy; elimination of economic classes, but reinforcement of racial classes
- Russo-Japanese War (1904–1905)
- After the winning the Russo-Japanese War, Japan was almost considered a Western country due to its military strength and ability to best a European country
- Japan is shown as both the model minority and the yellow peril; thought of as a threat to the West, but also considered the “most intelligent” Asian country
- Important to note that Russia was considered a hybrid of East and West
- London’s interpretation of the war was that Japan’s victory could awaken China’s power as another “yellow peril” power
- US colonization of the Philippines (1899)
- Reverse of the yellow peril; Philippines were thought of as an endless supply of steady labor
- Idea of the White Man’s Burden and the responsibility of Americans to bring civilization to the Philippines