Chapter 7: Consumers, Producers, and the Efficiency of Markets

  • Welfare Economics: The study of how the allocation of resources affects economic well-being
    • Answers questions about how to best organize economic activity

7-1: Consumer Surplus

Willingness to pay

  • Willingness to pay: The maximum amount a buyer will pay for a good; represents what a buyer values a good at
  • Consider the following scenario where four people want to buy an album:
Buyer Willingness to Pay
Taylor 100
Carrie 80
Rihanna 70
Gaga 50
  • In an auction, the price would raise to 80$, and Taylor would buy it at 80$ or more (because Carrie is unwilling to pay more)
    • Taylor’s consumer surplus is her willingness to pay minus the price she paid
    • If there are two albums to sell, then both Taylor and Carrie receive a consumer surplus, and the total market consumer surplus rises

Using the Demand Curve to Measure Consumer Surplus

  • Can use the demand schedule shown above to create a demand curve
    • Price is represented by the marginal buyer, or the buyer that would leave if the price was raised
    • Graph: Screen Shot 2022-10-18 at 8 54 46 PM
    • Depending on the quantity, the price of the album drops according to each buyer’s willingness to pay
    • The area below the demand curve and above the price measures the consumer surplus in a market.
    • Graph: Screen Shot 2022-10-18 at 8 58 44 PM
  • Demand curve represents maximum willingness to pay

How a Lower Price Raises Consumer Surplus

  • At lower prices, the price of the good is lower than more consumers’ value of the good, thus leading to a higher consumer surpus
  • Graph: Screen Shot 2022-10-18 at 9 00 02 PM

What Does Consumer Surplus Measure?

  • Consumer surplus is a good measure of economic well-being from the perspective of the buyers, as they are getting good value
  • Consumer surplus can sometimes be ignored in a market; lowering the price of heroine is not good but would increase consumer surplus

7-2: Producer Surplus

Cost and the Willingness to Sell

  • Cost: The value of everything (resources, manpower, time) that a seller uses to produce a good, essentially equivalent to willingness to sell
  • Consider the following scenario where four sellers are competing to paint a house:
Seller Cost
Vincent 900
Claude 800
Pablo 600
Andy 500
  • In an auction, the price would start high and quickly lower to 500$; Andy would offer a price of 600$ or slightly lower and take the job (because Pablo is unwilling to sell for lower than 600$)
    • Andy’s consumer surplus is the price he sells his service at minus his cost of production
    • If there are two houses to paint, then Pablo and Andy will both receive a producer surplus, and the total market producer surplus rises

Using the Supply Curve to Measure Producer Surplus

  • Can use the supply schedule shown above to create a supply curve
    • Price is represented by the marginal seller, or the seller that would leave if the price was lowered
    • Graph: Screen Shot 2022-10-18 at 9 09 20 PM
    • Depending on the quantity, the price of the service raises according to each seller’s cost
    • The area below the price and above the supply curve measures the producer surplus in a market.
    • Graph: Screen Shot 2022-10-18 at 9 11 08 PM

How a Higher Price Raises Producer Surplus

  • A higher price increases producer surplus because more producers get a higher profit margin for their service
  • Graph: Screen Shot 2022-10-18 at 9 12 49 PM

7-3: Market Efficiency

The Benevolent Social Planner

  • Consider a dictator who wants to maximize economic well-being in society
  • Can calculate total surplus in a market by adding consumer and producer surplus
    • Total surplus = Value to buyers - Cost to sellers = Buyers’ willingness to pay - Sellers’ cost
  • An allocation of resources that maximizes total surplus exhibits **efficiency**
    • Inefficient allocations include ones where producers are, wastefully, having higher costs to produce or ones where goods aren’t consumed by buyers who value them the most
  • Equality: Whether buyers and sellers both have similar levels of economics well-being
  • Thinking of the market as a pie, efficiency attempts to make the pie as big as possible while equality attempts to split it evenly

Evaluating the Market Equilibrium

  • At the equilibrium, the buyers who value the good the most and the sellers who have the lowest cost both consume/produce the good; therefore, the market equilibrium represents the greatest total surplus
    • Graph: Screen Shot 2022-10-18 at 9 19 52 PM
  • Free markets also naturally produce the quantity of goods which maximize total surplus; reducing the quantity creates a shortage, while increasing the quantity creates a surplus
    • Graph: Screen Shot 2022-10-18 at 9 22 08 PM
  • The benevolent dictator need not intervene; the invisible hand of the market will do everything for them